It was through the efforts of Father Verwyst, who was the pastor in New London (1865 to 1867), that the congregation of Bear Creek was organized and the building of the first church begun. The first church started to be built in 1867 but was not completed until 1868. It was built on what is now the corner of Highway 45 and Blueberry Road. Michael Cayton donated the land for the new church.  It measured 22 x 30 feet, twelve foot ceiling and fourteen pews. Although the first Mass offered in the church, by Father La Magie, was in the summer of 1868, it was not yet completed. The first marriage ceremony performed in the church was that of John Mares to Appolonia Gotten in the summer of 1869. Confirmation was held in the Northport church. 

St. Mary became the mission of St. Patrick of Lebanon in 1872.  In 1872 Father Duer became resident pastor at Lebanon and continued until the summer of 1881 when Father P.J. Lockamn was appointed resident pastor at Clintonville. St. Mary was then transferred to Clintonville.

Bear Creek Corners was, at the time, the beginning of a little rural community with a saloon, store and some houses. Present day Highway 45 was know as Shawano Road that went from Shawano to Oshkosh. The Northwestern Railway had not yet extended its tracks beyond Appleton.

The first church, completed in 1868, served its purpose until about 1885 when the Lake Shore Railway built its line from Appleton to Antigo. The tracks were laid about a mile from the village (Bear Creek Corners). The village soon began to build up around the railroad. More Catholic families had arrived and the railway brought more people and soon a need for a larger church was realized. It was decided to build it near the railway station. This church was built what would be behind the present day church. The present church was completed in 1922.

In 1895, St. Mary Parish got its first resident priest. He was Father E. E. Leccia who was succeeded by Father Per van Heyster. (Click here to view a list of priest who have served the parish.)

During this time the mission of St. Catherine of Alexandria at Helena* was organized and was put in charge of the pastor of St. Mary until 1926 when the mission parish closed. The graves in the parish cemetery were exhumed and most were moved to St. Mary Cemetery.

The above photo is a thumbnail.

The 1952 graduation class at St. Mary School.  Fr. H. A. Littel is pastor. Bishop Robert Morneau, now the Auxiliary Bishop of the Green Bay Diocese, is standing, first on the far left.

In 1970, Bishop John B. Grellinger, Pastor, encouraged parishioners and worked with them to refinish the pews. The interior of the church was painted and reredos screen was erected on which the new statue of the risen Christ was hung. In 1973, the spire was added to the roof to enhance the outside appearance of the church.

In 1997, with Msgr. Mark Schommer as Pastor, a group of parishioners worked diligently for many long hours to again refinish the pews and furniture. A new floor was laid, carpeting installed the church was cleaned and other necessary repairs were completed. An interior decorator was hired to paint and preserve the eminent beauty of the church.

The above photos are of the 1997 renovation.

With the interior of the church in beautiful condition, Father Don Everts had the exterior of our brick church cleaned and tuck-pointed. The former convent was removed  and the basement filled in. The parish house as extensively and beautifully renovated. 

A very special thank you to Kathy Klegin who provided the information for this history.

Priest Who Served St. Mary Parish